Over the last decades, increases in computing power and game development techniques have allowed virtual worlds to become increasingly complex, allowing for exponential immersion and engagement with the player (Ryan, Rygby and Przybylski, 2006). This evolution has also prompted the study of factors behind player engagement in video games, in particular with regards to intrinsic motivation. According to the self-determination theory (SDT), intrinsic motivation relies on triggering three key feelings (Ryan and Deci, 2000): autonomy, representing player choice; competence, the ability to fulfil goals and challenges; and, lastly, relatedness, the sense of belonging in the game world and relating to it as the playing character. These feelings, considered necessary for successful play in general (Frederick and Ryan, 1993), are derived from the player being ““in-character” within a particular gaming context” (Ryan, Rygby and Przybylski, 2006) and can explain why players find some games satisfying and, in turn, fun (Malone and Lepper, 1987). The essay will use the SDT theory to analyse how Yakuza 0 (Sega, 2015) uses these three intrinsic motivation factors to create engagement and a sense of fun with the player. Lastly, the essay will examine the limitations of Yakuza 0’s implementation of the theory.
Autonomy: Freedom and Empowerment
According to SDT, an initial intrinsic motivation factor is autonomy, in other words “the feeling that you are acting volitionally” (Recchia, 2013). It is important to player motivation as it creates a sense of agency, allowing players to feel a sense of empowerment in shaping the game’s narrative (Ryan, Rygby and Przybylski, 2006).
Yakuza 0’s main narrative is centred around story chapters that have to be played in order, and are triggered willingly by the player through a map marker. Each chapter represents a self-contained story following the main narrative thread, and often involves a unique location that cannot be accessed again or beforehand; once completed, the player returns to the game world and recovers full freedom and map access. At first glance, this makes for a very rigid system, as player agency is not involved in the main narrative structure in terms of story choices, or events order. However, Yakuza 0 uses a simple mechanic to mitigate this set-up : the player can choose exactly when to advance the story and do these chapters and does not get punished (or rewarded) for choosing when they want to trigger the next story chapter.
Figure 1: Once outside of a scenario chapter, the game emphasises the player freedom in the map
Autonomy is however developed significantly outside these story chapters: barring very few story-related exceptions, the player then has full freedom over the map and over the many activities it contains, which the game encourages the player to remember (figure 1); the player can undertake any other task in the game world and in any order. This is of particular relevance when considering the high amount of side-quests (100), and the length and narrative importance of each character’s business activity quests (Kiryu Kazuma’s estate management, and Majima Goro’s club management). Indeed, both quest types provide a significant amount of narration, character progression and rewards, in addition to unlocking further locations and mini-games; accordingly, they represent a large amount of in-game time and activities (figure 2).
Figure 2: Completion list showing the large amount of trackable activities and mini-games
These side-quests may be completed in any order without any prompters or restrictions, and can also be ignored without any penalty, an important factor as autonomy is based on the “degree of choice one has over the tasks and goals undertaken” (Ryan, Rygby and Przybylski, 2006). It is also interesting to note that, once again, the game does not punish or restrict the player by forcing them to complete the side quests within a set amount of time to before the end of the game, emphasising that the player can choose exactly when to handle them.
Equal freedom is applied to the plethora of mini-games available on the map (darts, bowling, pool, karaoke, dancing, arcade games, shoji, gambling, etc.), which can be accessed at any time and can also lead to further quests and narrative or gameplay rewards.
This variety of quests and activities outside of the main narration, and the freedom offered to the player regarding their completion rate and order, allows the game to carefully “balance [the player’s] boundless curiosity against a finite pool or resources” (Ryan, Rygby and Przybylski, 2010), allowing the player to make their own game by choosing what to do and when. In other words, as highlighted by Schell (2015, p.150), this allows Yakuza 0 to be a “game that gives you freedom to play how you want to play”, a crucial factor for autonomy.
Competence: Immediate Feedback and Gradual Mastery
SDT also highlights the need for competence, an intrinsic motivator representing the ability for the player to be challenged, to gradually master game mechanics, and to feel a sense of overall mastery progress. The feeling of competence is among the most important factors of satisfaction and therefore key to successful motivation, as it is directly linked to the player feeling accomplishment and control (Ryan, Rygby and Przybylski, 2006).
An initial application of competence is to make the player feel they are “effective and successful moment to moment” (Recchia, 2013), which Yakuza 0 achieves through combat. As a brawler-focused action game, Yakuza 0 allows the player to get into regular fights and to get immediate feedback through fighting rewards (figure 3): for every successful hit, money will fly out of the enemy and into the protagonist’s wallet and enemies’ health will go down, displaying the important immediate and visible feedback highlighted by Ryan, Rygby and Przybylski (2006).
Figure 3: Combat feedback through flying money and health damage
Another important factor to enhance competence is through “opportunities to acquire new skills and abilities” (Ryan, Rygby and Przybylski, 2006). To achieve this, Yakuza 0 makes use of a skill tree directly linked to combat: with money gained, players can unlock new skills and special moves, and can then apply them straight away to further their fighting ability and variety. This is further enhanced by the scaling of enemy difficulty in-game: as the game progresses, enemies’ health bars will grow longer, and they will equip gradually more lethal weapons such as swords and guns, which need to be dodged or will cause significant hinderance to the player and severely damage their health. This is an important feature which triggers more competence as “tasks within the game provide ongoing optimal challenge” (Ryan, Rygby and Przybylski, 2006): gradual evolution of in-game fights gives constant and gradual challenges that the player must adapt to and overcome, and trigger more competence motivation.
Figure 4: The karaoke mini-game, requiring simple button presses to score points. The reward video is also pictured here.
Interestingly, Yakuza 0 explores the concept of challenge through non-violent activities as well in mini-games like karaoke. Competence is approached differently but is nonetheless present: the player must press the right button at the right time, through an intuitive and simple interface. Feedback, in this case, is presented in an audio-visual form, with a music video unlocking to reward the player who has consistently pressed the right buttons at the right time (figure 4). While the competence in this mini-game does not progress with time as combat difficulty does, it is instead the player skill that is allowed to progress through repetition. Once again, players are never penalised for failing and may re-try the mini-games as often and whenever they choose. This provides an interesting alternative of triggering competence, this time occurring when “game controls are intuitive and readily mastered” (Ryan, Rygby and Przybylski, 2006).
Relatedness: Feeling and Belonging
Beyond autonomy and completion, Yakuza 0 uses another factor outlined in SDT to help the player feel an increased sense of intrinsic motivation: relatedness. Relatedness, also referred to as “presence”, can be described as a need based on interaction and as the “desire for connection with others - to feel that one matters” (Recchia, 2013). While it can be initially perceived to require a multi-player experience and interaction with other real people, it is important to note that this is also a feature that can be found in single-player games. Indeed, this is explicitly noted by Recchia who states that “we can feel a degree of relatedness even to game characters”. When Ryan and Deci (2000) discuss relatedness as “the need to feel belongingness”, taken to the context of a video game, it can therefore be assumed that in-game characters can be part of the equation.
Yakuza 0, as a narration-driven game, achieves this through several mechanics. While the player does not make in-game decisions that can change the main storyline, they are exposed to several recurrent characters and build a relationship with them throughout the game through various friendship activities (karaoke, darts, dancing), but also via the scenario and regular cut-scenes. These story pieces help create empathy though emotional cut- scenes, fully voiced and realistically modelled, where characters close to the protagonists can be seen addressing the player while in emotional distress or danger (figure 5). These help create a sense of empathy with the in-game characters, and to feel, as Reccha (2013) notes in his description of relatedness “that one matters and that one matters to others”.
Figure 5: An emotional cut-scene involving a protagonist and someone close to them in a state of distress.
In parallel, Yakuza 0 also achieves this through lighter-toned side quests where the protagonists must help various characters in the game world, usually to overcome hardships or to help fulfil their wishes. The humorous tone used in this narration can also help the player feel that they are connected to others, another important factor to achieve relatedness (Ryan and Deci, 2000) (figure 6).
Figure 6: A quest outcome emphasising the connection between the protagonist and the quest giver
More pragmatically, it is worth noting that Yakuza 0 also uses its game world to create relatedness, triggering “the sense that one is within the game world” (Ryan, Rygby and Przybylski, 2006). Indeed, in their study questions, they use the following question to assess the sense of presence with study participants: “when moving through the game world I feel as if I am actually there”.
Accordingly, Yakuza 0 uses high fidelity graphics to recreate a virtual version of two of Tokyo and Osaka’s districts, Kabukicho and Dotonburi respectively (Kamurocho and Sotenbori in-game), going as far as recreating the exact streets and shops from the real-life location, including notable tourist sights like Osaka’s Kani Doraku restaurant and its iconic billboard (figures 7 and 8).
Use of a night and day cycle and of various background noises (pedestrians talking, pachinko machine sounds, music playing when getting close to bars and clubs, thugs calling the protagonists from afar for fights) also help enhance the sense of presence and induce the player into feeling they are one with the time and space.
Figure 7: Iconic Osaka restaurant Kani Doraku in real life…
Figure 8: … and in-game.
The Limits of Intrinsic Motivations in Yakuza 0
While Yakuza 0 makes use of the aforementioned SDT triggers, it is worth remembering, as noted above, that they do not apply to all the elements in-game; for instance, autonomy does not apply to all the narration. However, as explained by Reccha (2013) this is not necessarily an issue as the key is the player’s perception that they can achieve autonomy. For instance, he notes that for SDT elements to be achieved it is enough to “feel that one’s actions are volitional and self-directed even if the game is in fact nudging them in a certain direction”. It can therefore be argued that, although Yakuza 0’s main narrative thread itself breaks autonomy, it is enough for the player to be nudged towards it; as mentioned above, this is also mitigated by wide variety and meaningfulness of side quests in terms of narration.
More generally, with regards to competence and relatedness, it can also be remarked that SDT principles may not work for certain players who will not enjoy the game’s mechanics enough to feel competence, or engage with the characters and world enough to feel relatedness. Indeed, as recognised and noted by Ryan, Rygby and Przybylski (2006) in their studies outcome, “there is considerable variation between individuals in their overall experience of and motivation for computer games”. While this does not invalidate the positive experience with regards to intrinsic motivation that some players will experience playing Yakuza 0, as with most subjective theories, it will not apply to every single player.
Yakuza 0 makes extensive use of the three Self-Determination Theory triggers to motivate players. It uses its extensive side-quest system and numerous mini-game activities to instil a sense of autonomy, allowing the players the important feeling of choice and empowerment. Yakuza 0 also makes use of its combat system to to give players a sense of completion, through direct rewards such as money and health damage, but also though long-term difficulty curve and special abilities unlocks over the course of the game. Through its narration, characters and settings, the game also instils a sense of relatedness with the player, giving them the chance to feel part of a world and linked to its inhabitants. Finally, it is worth noting that, as noted in STD and motivation studies, not all participants will be affected by SDT triggers the same way, meaning that while Yakuza 0’s application of SDT principles will be very successful with some players, it will not be universal.
Frederick, C. and Ryan, R. (1993) ‘Differences in Motivation for Sport and Exercise and Their Relations with Participation and Mental Health’. Journal of Sport Behavior, 16, pp.124–146.
Malone, T. and Lepper, M. (1987) ‘Making learning fun: A Taxonomy of Intrinsic Motivations in Learning’. Aptitude, Learning and Instruction, 3, pp. 223–253.
Recchia, G. (2013) Self-Determination Theory at GDC. Gamasutra. Available at: https://www.gamasutra.com/blogs/GabrielRecchia/20130329/189588/Selfdetermination_theory_at_GDC.php (Accessed 21 November 2017).
Ryan, R. and Deci, E. (2000) ‘Self-Determination Theory and the Facilitation of Intrinsic Motivation, Social Development, and Well-Being’, American Psychologist, 55(1), pp.68-78. Available at: citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.529.4370&rep=rep1...pdf (Accessed: 21 November 2017)
Ryan, R., Rigby, C. and Przybylski, A. (2006) ‘The Motivational Pull of Video Games: A Self-Determination Theory Approach’, Motivation and Emotion, 30(4), pp.344-360. Available at: https://selfdeterminationtheory.org/SDT/.../2006_RyanRigbyPrzybylski_MandE.pdf (Accessed: 21 November 2017).
Ryan, R., Rigby, C. and Przybylski, A. (2010) ‘A Motivational Model of Video Game Engagement’, Review of General Psychology, 14(2), pp.154-166.
Schell, J. (2015) The Art of Game Design: A Book of Lenses. Boca Raton: CRC Press.
Sega (2015) Yakuza 0. Sega.
Kani Doraku Image (2012). Available at: https://whereisfatboy.blogspot.co.uk/2012/06/osaka-kani-doraku-crab-feast.html (Accessed: 21 November 2017)
Sega (2015) Yakuza 0. Sega. All images my own.